The Cow Creek Band of Umpqua Tribe of Indians teamed up with Lone Rock Timber Management Company to create the sole proposal to buy 82,500 acres of the Elliott State Forest from the state of Oregon.
With the help and support of the Confederated Tribes of Coos, Lower Umpqua and Siuslaw Indians and The Conservation Fund, the partnership hopes to manage the land for timber harvest while providing 40 jobs per year and protecting the environment and public access.
“Tribes have always had a large role in managing the lands,” said Michael Rondeau, CEO of the Cow Creek Tribe. “Tribes didn’t own the land, the land owned them, and it’s part of their harmony with the resources available to them. We belong to the land, we’re a function of nature.”
The tribes understand that people have an important role in the ecosystem and in nature, added Tim Vredenburg, director of Forest Management for the tribe.
Roseburg-based business Lone Rock Timber Management Company has operated in Oregon forests f…
When there’s something special on the landscape, Vredenburg said, the western conservation approach is to draw a line around it and stay away, but he sees the tribe doing the opposite. It is actively involved in managing the land and interacting with the ecosystem in such a way to preserve the habitats, old growth reserves and streams while allowing for resource extraction and fuel management.
“No matter what a Native American Indian tribe does in terms of forest management,” Vredenburg said, “they live with the consequences of those actions. If they were to create smoke, they would breathe the smoke, if they muddied the water, they’d have to drink it and if they created a fire-prone forest, they’d live in a dangerous place.”
While most public agencies will write management plans for a 10- to 20-year time period, the tribe’s sense of consequence spans for at least seven generations.
“The tribes have been here for thousands of years and will continue to be here. This is our home,” Rondeau said.
Evan Smith of The Conservation Fund added that unlike other timber investors who might decide to pick up and move away, the tribes stay and are committed to the local community.
“They have this very patient, restorative approach to forestry that is rare to see in timber land managers these days,” Smith said.
The Cow Creek Tribe also takes on a holistic view of the forest that is not motivated by a short-term profit, according to Smith.
“Tribes look at natural resources a little bit differently than mainstream white culture,” Smith said, adding that while a lot of environmentalists see a stark divide between timber and natural resource protection, tribes see whole forests that they’ve been actively managing for centuries.
Dr. John Gordon, former dean of forestry at Yale University, said the general attitude shared by many tribes, including Cow Creek, is that they see the big picture and try to accomplish the best joint solution for resources, habitat, water and other factors.
Editor’s Note: This is the third in a four-part series about the partners proposing to purch…
“They see all the different facets together instead of trying to manage them separately,” Gordon said.
This holistic approach includes frequently burning undergrowth to control hazardous fuels, creating open areas for wildlife habitat and managing for sustainable timber production at the same time.
The frequent burns have historically been an important part of Cow Creek’s management to maintain a healthy forest where it is easier to hunt and gather. The tribe often burned huckleberries and other natural crops each year to improve production for the next season.
Historically, trees were spaced further apart with less dead material on the ground and undergrowth that could carry a fire up to the top of large trees.
“With the lack of that regular activity, the forest has become dense and overcrowded and less healthy, so now the tribes are looking at a much different forest today than 200 years ago,” Vredenburg said.
“When the fuels build up, it sets the stage for these catastrophic fires that can take the land out of commission for a generation,” Rondeau said.
In the Elliott, the Cow Creek Tribe and its partners are required to manage for sensitive habitats, particularly in riparian areas to keep stream temperatures down and protect listed and endangered species including the coho salmon, marbled murrelet, spotted owl and bald eagles.
“They’re very aware of that, and I’m sure because of their tribal values, not just because of the laws, they will be very careful about that,” Gordon said.
Cow Creek’s practices are also meant to contribute to a quality watershed with healthy salmon populations and more fishing opportunities while creating sustainable forms of revenue to support programs like elder services, health and education.
The Cow Creek Tribe has a long history of managing forestland in the area where Douglas County now exists. In the Elliott, trees were sparse, grass grew head high and there were plenty of meadows for elk to graze.
However, the tribe was terminated in the 1850s and many of the traditional forestry practices were taken away with their land.
Now, Rondeau’s generation is one of the first to have timber land again.
Vredenburg said between the time the tribe was occupying its ancestral lands and now, the forest has changed dramatically, with more timber crowded together.
Gordon, who’s also the co-chairman of the three assessments for the National Indian Forest Resources Management Act, found through his site visits across the country that where tribal lands exist, forest management is going well, but the tribes are underfunded and the lands are increasingly threatened by wildfire, disease, insects, development, climate change, urbanization and declining access to markets.
“With the small amount of land they have now, we’re trying to employ modern techniques while blending traditional knowledge and we’re looking at using a variety of different approaches from variable retention harvesting and reintroducing fire to those landscapes in a thoughtful way,” Vredenburg said of Cow Creek.
“That does include logging, and while logging can be controversial, our goal is to leave a plot in the position where it can become healthy again and to contribute to it being healthy now, whether it’s through thinning or other methods,” Rondeau added.
Cow Creek had a treaty in 1854 to designate a permanent reservation, but the treaty was never recognized. The tribe is hoping that Congress will finally create the reservation. In the meantime, Cow Creek has a goal to buy back its historic forestland that is now under federal ownership.
“I wish them well in their efforts and I’m very glad they continue to work toward forestry management as a long-term economic development tool,” said Wayne Shammel, the former attorney for Cow Creek. He retired from that position in 2014 after 19 years of providing legal counsel, drafting legislation for land acquisitions and lobbying to get the lands placed in a trust.
“It’s been in the long-term strategic plan of the tribe since its restoration and having been there a long time it’s nice to see they’re continuing their efforts to not just acquire land but work cooperatively with the regional timber companies and forestry management,” Shammel said. “It looks like some of their efforts are beginning to mature. I know they’ve completed some sales and they have done some harvests and things seem to be progressing well and I’m happy for them.”
Though the Cow Creek tribe and the Confederated Tribes haven’t been able to regain a large portion of their ancestral lands, they do a good job with what they have, Gordon said.
“They do a very good job of blending the objective of environmental health and timber production ... they’re able to do both,” Gordon said. “The forests these tribes are in are some of the most productive forests anywhere.”
Though the Cow Creek Tribe has yet to regain much of its original land, it does manage what it has sustainably, according to Gordon.
Before coming to work for the tribe, Vredenburg helped manage the Coquille Indian Tribe’s portion of regained land, according to the parameters of the Northwest Forest Plan, protecting water quality, habitats and old growth stands while producing an average of 3 million board feet per year.
“They did so successfully, so that’s the only land under the Northwest Forest Plan where both the environmental and timber targets have been met,” Gordon said.
Douglas County has been the epicenter of controversy around timber harvest and endangered species, particularly the spotted owl, but Vredenburg and Rondeau said Cow Creek can help provide models of a good approach to forest management that not only maintains the forest and its surrounding community, but improves it.
“I’m hoping through Tim’s leadership and the tribe’s historical desire to improve the landscape, we can provide methods and examples for others in the timber industry and environmentalists that can learn there is a happy medium,” Rondeau said.
“That’s one of our hopes in the Elliott project and really through anything the tribe works on, using traditional knowledge and blending that with modern technology and science to show relevant and effective management methods that support all the things we care about in the forest,” Vredenburg said.