About 25 people turned out for a presentation and question-answer session about vaccinations Thursday night at CHI Mercy Medical Center for a discussion about the effectiveness and safety of vaccinations.

The event was put on by Evergreen Family Medicine in Roseburg and Dr. Tim Powell, the CEO and medical director of Evergreen, who told the audience that he deeply believes in the value of immunizations.

“There is no question, no reasonable person anywhere would argue whether or not vaccines work,” he said. “Of course they work.”

But he added that the more difficult discussion is if vaccinations are safe.

“And they’re not perfectly safe, but they are a lot safer than the disease, and the risks are very small,” Powell said.

Not everyone agreed. Shawn Kellim said he raised a son and fully vaccinated him. The son is now 20 years old and has chronic asthma. Kellim said he can’t attribute that to anything in particular, but he wonders if the vaccines might have had something to do with it.

“My position is if you want to vaccinate your child, fine, but do the research, and I want to have that same ability as a parent to look at it and say, ‘there’s too many unknowns here,’” Kellim said. “There are far too many holes in the things that we’re being told.”

Powell said Evergreen has decided not to treat children whose parents choose not to allow the vaccinations.

“We will not participate in their care, they’re a danger to our other patients,” Powell said.

Powell said he supports HB 3063 in the Oregon Legislature, a bill that would remove non-medical exemptions for school-aged children, but it won’t have much effect on what Evergreen does.

“Truly, it won’t change anything that I’ve done, because at Evergreen, we’ve already taken that stand,” Powell said. “I believe a decision not to immunize your children is tantamount to neglect and I won’t be a partner in that.”

Kellim said he’s opposed to not having a choice.

“I’m very opposed to the state telling me that I have to do anything,” Kellim said. “What’s going to happen when they figure out that this vaccine doesn’t actually produce life-long immunity.”

HB 3063 is expected to get a full vote of the Oregon House of Representatives on Monday.

The bill would remove the ability of parents to decline required immunizations against restrictable diseases on behalf of a child for a reason other than the child’s indicated medical diagnosis.

The bill is scheduled to be voted on Monday and is expected to pass the House, but it could have a tougher time in the Senate.

Reporter Dan Bain can be reached at 541-957-4221 or e-mail at dbain@nrtoday.com.

React to this story:



Dan Bain is the health reporter for The News-Review. He previously worked at KPIC and 541 Radio.

(1) comment


Good for Dr. Powell, for stating the truth: insufficiently protecting your child from preventable disease is neglect. I would go further.
Fear, ignorance, and rising paranoia stalk the land like a plague. “I’m very opposed to the state telling me that I have to do anything,” Kellim said; what about speed limits? Licensing for physicians? Taxes? We should also note that the proposed legislation would not prevent his forgoing immunizations for his children; only that his children could not infect other children at school. I would go a lot further than that, personally.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.